(no subject)
Aug. 16th, 2008 06:45 pmI was greatly disappointed by Timothy Findley's Pilgrim. I had high hopes for it -- I mean, how could you go wrong with Findley writing a magic realism piece about Carl Jung? He's a great craftsman, and it's great material.
The first fifty and last hundred pages were excellent -- pity that it's a 520-page book. The middle is a sandwich of Findley's usual obsessions -- bad fathers, bad psychiatrists, bad fathers, bad psychiatry, bad fathers, World War I, bad husbands, and bad fathers.
We've seen it all before. He did it much better in Headhunter, The Wars, and Famous Last Words. This mixes those three books together into a rather unsatisfying glop.
Also, the spirit of Leonardo of Vinci probably prefers his portrayal in the Da Vinci Code to Findley's version of him.
I can't say I'm used to straight authors portraying homosexual men as monstrous rapists of children and adults, or particularly grotesque johns and sugar daddies. But from a gay author like Timothy Findley -- who spent the last 51 years in what was by all accounts a happy marriage and artistic collaboration writer Whitehead -- it'd be nice to have, say, one gay character who didn't read like a propaganda pamphlet from the religious right.
At least his Oscar Wilde wasn't that vile.
The first fifty and last hundred pages were excellent -- pity that it's a 520-page book. The middle is a sandwich of Findley's usual obsessions -- bad fathers, bad psychiatrists, bad fathers, bad psychiatry, bad fathers, World War I, bad husbands, and bad fathers.
We've seen it all before. He did it much better in Headhunter, The Wars, and Famous Last Words. This mixes those three books together into a rather unsatisfying glop.
Also, the spirit of Leonardo of Vinci probably prefers his portrayal in the Da Vinci Code to Findley's version of him.
I can't say I'm used to straight authors portraying homosexual men as monstrous rapists of children and adults, or particularly grotesque johns and sugar daddies. But from a gay author like Timothy Findley -- who spent the last 51 years in what was by all accounts a happy marriage and artistic collaboration writer Whitehead -- it'd be nice to have, say, one gay character who didn't read like a propaganda pamphlet from the religious right.
At least his Oscar Wilde wasn't that vile.